Manga – Jisatsu Circle [REVIEW] – The Suicide Club

MyAnimeList Rating: 6,88/10
Genres: Horror, Psychological
Author: Usamaru Furuya (Story & Art)
Serialization: None


One year after the movie with the same title, Sion Sono’s “Suicide Club” was finally adapted to the manga written by Usamaru Furuya with the same title. It’s not his first work I’ve read from the author. Previously, I had read “No Longer Human” adapted from a novel with the same title by Osamu Dazai which was used as a reference in a show called “Aoi Bungaku Series,” involved five directors including Tetsurou Araki who directed “Death Note” and Morio Asaka who directed “Cardcaptor Sakura.” It’s not one of the darkest or depressing even though because this is a short manga, it has the same story and premise as the movie about mass suicide by schoolgirls.

Jisatsu Circle” is a manga based on a movie of the same title, written and directed by Sion Sono. At first, the manga was intended to follow the same story, but Sion Sono asked Usamaru Furuya to adapt his own story to it, which resulted in a plot much easier to understand.

The story begins with the same opening scene, where 54 girls commit suicide by jumping in front of a moving train. However, one girl survives (Saya Kota) and opens another Suicide Club, with other victims. Her best friend, Kyoko, fears for Saya’s future and begins to search for the strange secrets surrounding the Suicide Club to try and save Saya and the other girls from committing such a tragedy again.

Source: MAL

JC1

While this is just a one-volume manga with six chapters, there isn’t much I can say from it. As begin with one of the most memorable, horrible, and disturbing opening sequences ever, it tells the story of Saya Kota who surviving mass suicide on a train where 50 more of schoolgirls died without being left. Saya Kota who survived the suicide slowly lost her both mentally and externally. In this case, Kyoko who is her best friend felt something empty inside her and tried to find out the ins and outs of the club, the terrifying history from the club, and why it could happen. I love this kind of story because, in the end, the story will continue in an endless-cycle without anything that stops, there will be other victims who fall continuously. Indeed, the story feels forced, there is no depth of the story, and it makes no any sense like I just don’t know why the people or adults in the manga didn’t take an action which one of the characters existed. In fact, there are so many plot holes which I don’t think are logic in the story apart from this is disturbing and creepy manga. Yet, six chapters at least making you as the worst nightmare for once.

JC2

The important point that leads to the horror aspect of this manga is that the art which is certainly so creepy. The character designs are almost all frightful, whatever anyone, the girls, the adults, the other characters, anything. They always make some various facial expressions which it makes me weird but not too creepy. This part also builds the mood of the characters because the design character looks like a bad person from the outside. Still, it got me some weird feeling from the gore aspect especially at the end of the story. Although Kyoko is the hero of this manga, Saya Kota is actually the main focused. We learn about her past, comparing her characteristics before joining the suicide club until it seems to be one of the brainwashed. The manga also explains the various dark events and history of the club itself, the former leaders before Saya Kota, and others. Sensei which helped through the story where I thought he was the person behind it or the bad guy, it’s not like that. This point, as well as what I said, seems forced and told in one story so that it’s forgettable.

JC3

I don’t know the obvious reason all characters in this manga of why they formed the club. The trick is if the story actually quite developing, deepening or maybe the story which is exiled by society, it might add to the impression but there is nothing like that. This kind of story is indeed interesting at certain points and I also can’t say how I feel. I don’t find it memorable because this is one of the most manga that can be read in just a few minutes. This manga mixes a feeling that I can’t understand but at the very least, it’s a bit enjoying with stories which are so depressing, creepy, but weird regardless of the plot holes.

2.5 Star


Jisatsu Circle” is not one of the bad ones with a concept that involves a society and dark yet terrifying impression. “No Longer Human” is one of the hard manga to read not because there are some lacks but it’s really hit at the certain point. This manga is also not recommended for people who don’t like gore, especially the body pieces. Various aspects are at least developed through a little because it might be more interesting to add some unique things from the characters or references from the movie which I haven’t watch the movie yet. “Jisatsu Circle” is not too memorable yet not too interesting but it’s one that I love about the horror which involves psychological and mental illness.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s